Dave Case Law

Precedents applied where Dave considers precedent helpful.

Reference FS-DAVE-CASE Authority Dave Status cited Review date 24 May 2026

Current authorities

Dave v Lighting

Neutral Light Principle

Dave held that poor lighting may reduce clarity but cannot extinguish confidence where confidence has already entered the record.

In Re: Thursday Socks

Provenance Test

Dave accepted that socks may be relevant where the weekday is stated, implied, or obvious to Dave on inspection.

The Cardigan Question

Outerwear Jurisdiction

Dave confirmed that a cardigan may be context, aggravating detail, or mitigation, depending on weave, posture, and Dave's mood.

Dave v The Chair

Furniture Involvement

A chair becomes involved when Dave says it is involved. No further test is required.

Pub Regular Reference

Verbal Evidence

Statements beginning "fair play" carry weight unless followed by "but", in which case Dave reserves judgement.

Becky Register Note

Continuity

Where an entrant appears with consistent administrative force, Dave may treat the register as settled until properly unsettled.